As the indie gaming industry continues to evolve, understanding the benchmarks for Steam wishlists per day has become crucial for developers seeking to maximise their success. In this comprehensive article, we’ll delve into the latest data and insights to help you navigate the complex world of Steam wishlist conversions and make informed decisions for your upcoming game releases.

Key Takeaways:

  • Median conversion rates for indie games with 25,000+ wishlists can forecast around 3,750 Week 1 sales

  • Median conversion for games with over 10,000 wishlists is around 0.17x (e.g., 50,000 wishlists → 8,500 sales)

  • For games priced over £10, median conversion drops to 0.10x (e.g., 100,000 wishlists → 10,000 sales)

  • First-month sales conversion averages 27% of launch wishlists, with first-week conversion around 20%

  • Top performers can exceed medians dramatically, with examples like InZOI at 3.2x, PEAK at 266x, and Revenge On Gold Diggers at 539x

Timing and Optimisation for Steam Wishlists

When it comes to release timing and store page optimisation, there are several key factors to consider. Avoid launching in December, as conversion rates tend to dip below the 0.15x median during this period. Additionally, top-converting games have averaged 214 days of pre-launch hype, compared to 411 days for less successful titles, as interest can fade over time.



Utilising Steam Next Fest demos can also provide a significant boost to conversions, as seen with YAPYAP, which saw its week 1 conversion rate jump from 3.3% to 5.5% after 23 days. Conversely, poor timing, such as a January 29th launch, can hurt conversions, as evidenced by The Midnight Walkers, which only converted 1.3% of its 87,000 wishlists.

Genre and Review Impact on Conversions

The genre of your game can also play a significant role in conversion rates. Online co-op titles, like the viral hit PEAK, have shown exceptional conversion rates of 266x. NSFW games have also demonstrated unusually high conversion rates as outliers. However, sequels can be more challenging, as they may face higher expectations from players.

The review score of your game is another crucial factor, with the top 20 performers averaging 91% versus the bottom 20 at 67%. Additionally, the lead time before launch has shown a significant impact, with top performers averaging 214 days compared to 411 days for less successful titles.

Benchmarking Top Wishlist Counts for Indies

To provide a frame of reference for indie developers, here are some notable Steam wishlist counts for relevant titles:

  • Crowsworn (34,831 wishlists)
  • BLACKFROST: The Long Dark 2 (39,737 wishlists)
  • Hela (28,267 wishlists)
  • Fate Trigger (50,514 wishlists)
  • Killer Bean (34,988 wishlists)
  • Derelicts (54,510 wishlists)
  • Prison Architect 2 (37,476 wishlists)
  • Tears of Metal (23,808 wishlists)
  • Holstin (30,058 wishlists)
  • Dinoblade (24,824 wishlists)
  • Bloody Hell Hotel (26,856 wishlists)

Additionally, some Steam top upcoming titles, like Subnautica 2 (3.8M wishlists), Slay the Spire 2, Kingmakers, Crimson Desert, and Blight: Survival, provide a glimpse into the broader Steam traffic and trends.

Conclusion

As the indie gaming landscape continues to evolve, understanding the benchmarks for Steam wishlists per day is crucial for developers seeking to maximise their success. By leveraging the insights and data presented in this article, you can make informed decisions about your game’s release strategy, optimise your store page, and position your title for maximum traffic and sales. Remember, the key to success lies in careful planning, genre-specific optimisation, and a deep understanding of your audience’s preferences.

Sources:
The state of Steam wishlist ‘conversions’: 2024-2025
Steam Wishlist-to-sales study shows how genre, release timing and reviews affect success
The top 2026 games by Steam wishlists
Wishlist-to-buyer conversions for games with Steam Next Fest demos
Steam’s most wishlisted games reveal an unexpected frontrunner
What is the typical conversion rate from Steam wishlists to game sales
What’s the Steam Wishlist to Sales Ratio in 2025?
The top 2026 games by Steam wishlists

author avatar
Josh
See Full Bio